Why We Choose a Partner That Fits with Our Past

Ask someone what they look for in a partner and they may say things like smart, funny, good-looking, and may even trustworthy, loyal, and kind, all the adjectives you might expect. If you give them a chance to probe a bit deeper, they’ll probably mention similar tastes in movies, music, in hobbies, or foods. Then there are personal likes and dislikes. Women usually say someone taller than them. While men explain certain physical attributes they find attractive. Few people would say, “They should remind me of my father” or “mother.”

Why do we choose partners so different from ourselves? It’s not fate or chance or cliches like, “the heart wants what the heart wants”. We choose our partners because they represent the unfinished business from our childhood. And we choose them because they manifest the qualities we wish we had. In doing so, in choosing such a challenging partner and working to give them what they need, we chart a course for our own growth. – Jay Pritchett, Modern Family 

But if you look closer, you’ll see that there is a strong connection between the milieu in which we were raised and the type of partner we choose. Have you ever noticed that people pick mates very much like their opposite sex parent or childhood caregiver? An “imago” (pronounced like embargo) is the image that’s build into our subconscious. It contains all the positive and negative qualities of our caregiver(s) who raised us. This becomes a template for the romantic partner we look for down the road.

When we first meet someone we’re attracted to, we may not be aware of what draws us in. When the way another person operates is familiar to us, it makes us feel comfortable and safe, like “we’ve known them forever.” We feel good around this person and are able to let our guard down, even to be vulnerable. This allows us to build intimacy, from which the relationship springs.

The theory was developed by psychologists and romantic partners Harville Hendrix, PhD and Helen LaKelly Hunt, PhD. Their work culminated in the bestseller, Getting the Love You Want, a groundbreaking work now celebrating its 20th anniversary.

Growing up, watching our parents or caregivers interact modeled for us adult relationships. How dad treated mom for instance, can communicate how a woman feels, subconsciously, she should be treated by her partner in adulthood. How mom treats dad models how she should act. This works for men as well. If a boy’s father treats his mother like a queen growing up, he’s likely to do the same when he’s a husband.

One problem that happens along the way is, a caregiver may fail to meet a child’s needs. The child then adapts to accommodate the situation. The first stage usually occurs between birth and a year and a half. This is when one’s attachment style starts to form. If the caregivers are loving and responsive to the baby’s physical and emotional needs, he or she develops a secure attachment style.

If they are unresponsive or neglectful, the child internalizes feelings of rejection and begins to withdraw. Later on, he or she will avoid interacting with others, including peers. As the child gets older, they learn to cater to their own needs and become what is known as an “avoider.”

Others have inconsistent caregivers when they’re small. Sometimes they’re neglectful and at others, attentive. This can give the child feelings of abandonment, leading to another insecure attachment style. This person becomes a “clinger.” One’s attachment style acts as a foundation, upon which future stages are built. Stages go all the way up to adolescence and in each phase, a new behavior or tendency is added.

At age three to four, one develops a sense of self. Depending on how well it goes, he or she can become a “controller,” “diffuser,” or “an integrated self.” At four to seven, the child starts to feel their own power. As a result, they might become empowered, a “compromiser,” or a “competitor.”

At seven to 13, they learn about friendship, which can teach them how to conduct healthy relationships. But they may also become a “loner” or a “caretaker,” who always puts others first, and hardly ever mentioning their own needs. Finally, there’s adolescence, where we develop positive sexual and emotional relationships, or become a “conformist” or even a “rebel.” Each stage adds another element to our personality and instructs us in how to manage our relationships and fall in love.

None of these are concrete, however. Behaviors can be situational. We may be an avoider in one instance, and securely attached in another. What tends to happen is, negative background experiences set one up, for what Dr. Hendrix calls, malatropism, or responding in the wrong way to a person or stimulus. Consider the little boy who runs up and punches the girl he likes. It’s the wrong response for what he secretly desires.

Some psychologists believe we pick certain partners for psychological healing, to work through unresolved issues. So what if you weren’t raised in the best environment or you keep picking the wrong people? Are you stuck? Fortunately, patterns can change.

Drs. Hendrix and Hunt created Imago Relationship Therapy, practiced by many couples counselors today. This is talk therapy arranged around structured dialogue, aiming at contingent communication. Each person starts to understand the meaning behind what the other person is saying, their motivation, what forces shaped them, and how they feel, deep down inside. As Dr. Hendrix wrote in the book, “We are born in relationship, we are wounded in relationship, and we can be healed in relationship.”

via Big Think

  • Palama
    30th Jan 2018

    Wow! What an amazing article. I have accepted I have a certain type. Always drawn to men that have a ‘presence’ and strong personality. My dad is such a man and smart too. Loves music. Politics. Looks good in a suit.

    I am trying to go for these timid and beta males but wow they not coming to the damn party.

    A lot of who we are is embedded in our childhood,some make the connection and some don’t.

    • TheLooz
      31st Jan 2018

      An old flame once said to me to stop going for men like myself i.e. smart and outspoken, because the clashes would never end. He said to rather go for the timid type, hahahahhahaha shuuuu, relationshipping is a hell of alot! Ngeke.

      • George Matsheke
        31st Jan 2018

        I love this though,

        We choose our partners because they represent the unfinished business from our childhood. And we choose them because they manifest the qualities we wish we had. In doing so, in choosing such a challenging partner and working to give them what they need, we chart a course for our own growth.

        • Sivu
          31st Jan 2018

          This particular part of the article hit me so hard! I find that I work more towards avoiding dating my dad. He’s great but I think I’m so aware of his flaws that I consciously look out for them 🙁 My dad was a mix of my dad and my late brother- stingy & a womaniser. It really felt like I was dealing with Big bro and Dad daily. Often wondering about other women. Having to put together a powerpoint presentation on why I deserve to be taken out!

          Bafethu!!! This relating business!!!!

      • Palama
        31st Jan 2018

        Heeee!heeeeee! A cousin of mine,male,drafted a plan for me. Basically I am must always be on the look out for these timid men,beta types…you will wait with these ones cos they hardly make any moves even if they know you have a lil’ crush. I guess to some extent,we attract who we are on a certain level. No formula really.

        • George Matsheke
          31st Jan 2018

          Im the timid type you have to patient with us and make some moves actually …

    • George Matsheke
      31st Jan 2018

      I date my mother shem, i made peace with and its ok even wrote this article about it (https://www.marvin.co.za/my-mother-my-girlfriend/)

      • Palama
        31st Jan 2018

        Can’t see the article,gives an error. Under normal circumstances that’s ideal but reminding a man of his mum,when they have a complex relationship,recipe for disaster.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: